HCSO Investigation Turns Up Surveillance of Missing Woman Prompting Search North of Myers Flat

HCSO and volunteer fire department personnel gather together as the search for Zoe Penrod continues. [Photo by Malachi Church]
Penrod was reported missing on January 1 after leaving her home on December 31, suffering from post-partum psychosis according to her fiancé David Boyett. Boyett told Redheaded Blackbelt in an interview that he had spoken with Penrod around 8:30 a.m. on December 31 in the yard of the couple’s residence. After checking on the couple’s five-month-old son, Boyett stated he returned to the yard to find Penrod had left.
After the initial report was made, personnel from the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office conducted a search of the area both on foot and using a drone, as well as interviewing Boyett, neighbors, and friends of Penrod, according to Second District Supervisor, Michelle Bushnell.
No clues to the missing mother’s whereabouts were discovered.

Zoe Penrod, missing from Myers Flat since December 31, 2023. [Photo provided by David Boyett]
Though the search did not reveal the whereabouts of Penrod, additional information was brought forward about a possible sighting of the missing 38-year-old north of Myers Flat along the Avenue of the Giants.
Malachi Church, a volunteer firefighter with the Salmon Creek Fire Protection District, was requested, along with other volunteers, to assist the HCSO in a search one mile north of Myers Flat.
In a phone interview, Church shared that searchers were given a flyer with a surveillance image of a person in what appeared to be a green bathrobe bathroom and green slipper-type shoes walking past the Drive Thru Tree located at the north intersection where Boy Scout Road meet the Avenue (Highway 254). Searchers were told that the image was of Zoe Penrod, however the image on the flyer was blurry.
Bushnell, who has been in close contact with search personnel and HCSO on the ongoing search efforts, shared an update from Sheriff William Honsal, who stated, “[The] Humboldt County Sheriff’s Department is searching areas off of [Highway] 254 due to recent information that [Zoe] was in the area on 12/31.”
Even with the inclement weather, approximately 50 searchers turned out today, attempting to locate the missing woman. “There [were] several different volunteer fire departments, and other volunteer organizations, represented there along with the Sheriff’s Department,” Church stated. “We had a wide variety of volunteers,” he said, including volunteers from Rio Dell and Blue Lake, and from as far away as Sonoma County.
Though searchers were drenched, they were happy to aid in the search efforts. “You get to show up and … there’s always a sense of community among volunteers. [A]ll of you are there, maybe for different reasons, but you’re all there for the same purpose,” Church stated.

Searchers from as far away as Sonoma County joined the HCSO in attempting to locate Zoe Penrod. [Photo by Malachi Church]
Today marks the tenth day since Zoe Penrod has been missing. If anyone has any information about her whereabouts or disappearance, they are encouraged to contact the Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office at 707-445-7251 or by calling the anonymous tip line at 707-268-2539. Any information may be valuable in the efforts to locate the missing woman.
Note: Malachi Church is the son of Redheaded Blackbelt Owner/Editor, Kym Kemp.
Earlier:
- [UPDATE 12:46 p.m.] Missing Myers Flat Woman May Be Experiencing a Mental Health Crisis
- Search Today in Myers Flat to Find Missing New Mother Zoe Penrod
- Concerned Community Member Initiates Search for Missing Mother
Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules
Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/
Sighs… so far, this is not a good story. :>(
—
Anything on the missing mushroom hunter at Smith River ?
Seems like they found her backpack… but nothing else.
Bad weather up there… chances of survival are dropping. Again… :>(
Thanks Malachi
Why haven’t they brought in a dog? They can cover ground and smell if she’s been around. Or drones at night with heat seeking features.
They did bring in search dogs today. I was there today and it was actually a well organized legitimate search finally…
I saw an article recently about hunters having good success with hear seeking drones finding lost dogs….why are they not deployed for humans? Although, I fear by now this woman is probably cold.
Can we get an updated flyer that does not include incorrect clothing information please?
Also with mention of red/auburn hair dye…
Such as wearing a green bathroom and slippers. Took a minute but i figured it means “bathrobe,” though such info seems a bit sketchy.
Thank you to everyone putting in the time and effort, I’m still hoping for the best.
Maybe an empty cabin or somewhere she could have holed up.
Yes! I am holding out hope for Zoe and her loved ones!
Green bath*robe*? And slippers?
So, where did his oversized shoes go that she was wearing? They already found her dress in her closet.
Did the fiance show up to help this past Sunday? The baby is in AZ. with relatives which indicates he would have time to help search.
I saw a sheriff vehicle towing an atv going into Hidden Springs south of Myers Flat around 12:30 this afternoon…
Idk I am sure everyone has already looked for her a long the avenue I would try dyerville loop road or the old Daly’s ranch
Humboldt seems to have more missing people than any other county. Wonder if there’s a rogue cop could be a serial killer?
More people disappear in Humboldt County than any other place on the planet.
The river is very close to where Zoe Penrod lives.
David knows. And now the psychedelic side chick who moved in right when Zoe started acting strange is saying she “just hopes she isn’t suffering”. It seems like she knows too.
Was she being ‘medicated’ ?
This feels all too familiar…
This beautiful lady has been failed~
David knows and now the psychedelic side chick who moved in right when Zoe started acting strange is saying she “just hopes she isn’t suffering”. It seems like she knows too.
hello. this might not be believed by some people, but my name is Angela Koenig. I am the eldest daughter of Zoe Estella Penrod. Zoe has never been incredibly involved in my life and i haven’t seen her in over 6+ years. If anyone has any information or anything that can be used to figure out what happened to my mother, I greatly appreciate it. Any theories or anything at all. I will be starting my own investigation and I will not stop until I find my mom! If anyone has any questions in regarding how I am Zoe Penrod’s daughter, ask away. This might not be believed but it will be fine. Just please let me know any information on what you think happened and what can we do to find her. Email me as well. with email down below. Stay safe guys.
Sincerely,
Angela Koenig