New NTSB Report Reveals Details of Fatal Covelo Plane Crash

NTSB’s photograph and diagram of the crash site [From the NTSB]

NTSB’s photograph and diagram of the crash site [From the NTSB]

New information has emerged about the October 2023 airplane crash near Covelo offering insights into the tragic event. According to a preliminary report from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), the Beechcraft A36, was destroyed in the crash, resulting in the deaths of pilot Vaughn Porter, 54, and his girlfriend, Jamie Rust, 51.

The Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association Airport Index describes the Round Valley Airport as being in a challenging location, surrounded by high mountains and ridges where mountain flying experience is “strongly recommended”. The pilot took off from Runway 28 and made a left turn, despite the right traffic pattern suggested by the airport index.

As described in the NTSB preliminary report, witnesses recounted seeing the airplane lift off near the departure end of runway 28 before beginning a left turn towards the northwest in a nose-high attitude. The aircraft then cleared a group of trees by about 20 feet while maintaining the left turn from approximately 60 feet above ground level. As it turned towards the south, the bank angle increased to about 70 degrees, and the airplane subsequently crashed, then exploded before catching on fire.

NTSB’s map of the incident

NTSB’s map of the incident

The NTSB report states that the airplane came to rest on a hillside about 0.4 nautical miles west of the departure end of Runway 28 at a field elevation of around 1,500 feet above ground level. 

Several 20-foot-tall trees with broken tops and branches marked the first point of impact. A 50-foot-long debris path led from the first point of impact to the main wreckage, which was mostly consumed by fire.

Further investigation revealed a significant difference in elevation between the ridgelines encountered depending on the turn direction. Mapping released by the NTSB showed that the ridgeline to the right of the departure end rose approximately 1,800 feet above ground level. In contrast, the ridgeline to the left, which the pilot would have observed while taking off, rose to 4,000 feet above ground level.

According to KSLTV5, Porter was a seasoned pilot with over 30 years of flying experience and more than 15 years with JetBlue. He and his girlfriend originally took off from Heber Valley Airport in Utah. The flight was bound for Shelter Cove on the Southern Humboldt Coast but diverted to Round Valley when the coastal destination was fogged in.

NTSB has yet to issue its final report which should provide a more comprehensive analysis of the conditions and circumstances that contributed to the crash.

Earlier:

Facebooktwitterpinterestmail

Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules

Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

9 Please improve the conversation by disagreeing thoughtfully and backing your claims with facts
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
farfromputin
Member
1 year ago

I will fly but only commercial, following advice from an old man. I’m sorry for the loss of these precious lives.

DHW
Guest
DHW
1 year ago
Reply to  farfromputin

that’s sad for you. I much prefer small airplanes to jets since they have a glide ratio when/if the engine fails.The jet is going to drop like a stone. This could be determined Pilort Error unless there was an unknown mechanical problem or medical issue.
Sad but any pilot that flies small planes understands the risks and pleasures of small planes. Great way to travel, IMHO.

Boffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  DHW

The type of engine has no bearing on glide ratio

Espino
Guest
Espino
1 year ago

As a resident of the valley and pilot who has flown in and out of this valley hundreds of times I’m mystified why he chose a westerly departure considering the calm winds on that day.

Zipline
Guest
Zipline
1 year ago
Reply to  Espino

Pilot error.

Permanently on Monitoring
Guest
Permanently on Monitoring
1 year ago

Bonanza A36, or, “Doctor Killer”…

It surprises me that an experienced pilot, a Professional Pilot, crashed this way…

I wouldn’t want a ride in a tiny plane again, after flying with a Former Fighter Pilot in a 10 seat Commercial Jet, from Oahu to Kauai in 1982…

We don’t really know what happened…

Martin
Guest
Martin
1 year ago

Condolences to the families and friends of Mr. Porter and Ms. Rust. I am so very sorry for your losses of your loved ones. May they RIP.

Truth Be Told
Member
Truth Be Told
1 year ago
Reply to  Martin

Your condolences are slightly belated – the plane crashed last October…

Martin
Guest
Martin
1 year ago
Reply to  Truth Be Told

Where are yours?