[UPDATE 10:21 p.m.: Good News!] A Community Worries That a Student Rafting Trip Is in Trouble
Concern is rising after a group of young students and three adults are almost completely out of touch since setting out on a rafting trip into the main stem of the Eel River about 3:30 p.m. on Tuesday. The leader sent one text reporting that there was an injury today, but there has been no further information.
According to residents of the area, there are nine boats and 17 people–three adults and 14 youth (all under 15, according to one local.)
Donna Sullins, who was hired to shuttle a vehicle from the put in area to the confluence of the Eel Rivers at Dyerville, tells us, “The kids [are] all from a private school in Berkeley.” Sullins says she was worried about the situation and tried to talk about the risks to the adults involved. “I just had a bad feeling…One of the moms got in my Jeep. I told her, ‘There ain’t no way in hell I would let my kid on the river [at this time].'”
Sullins was worried that the students weren’t prepared. She said the youth did have lifejackets, but, she told us, “The kids didn’t have no helmets on.”
Almost immediately after putting into the Eel River on Tuesday afternoon, two of the youths in one of the inflatable boats got swept into a shallower area beneath the Alderpoint bridge. One of the local women looking from the bridge told us, “Our river is so swollen and so swift not even a local would get in this river right now…There was a male and a female [student], very petite in size…As soon as they got in the swift part, it basically sucked them downriver to the willows in the center…They clearly didn’t know how to paddle their raft. It turned backwards and the river sucked them into the willows where it’s a little shallow there.”She said the boat was high centered and she was worried the inflatable craft might pop.
The kids were screaming for help and locals on the bridge tried to yell instructions on how to paddle out. But the roar of the river made hearing difficult. One of the adults on the bridge told us, “They were scared. The girl shouted, ‘Get us help! Get us help!'”
One of the adults with the school group, a young male estimated to be between 18 and 20 years old by people we talked to, had wanted to swim out to rescue the students but locals managed to talk him out of trying.
Sullins, referring to Zack Harrison swimming the Eel River by Alderpoint while fleeing a murder charge, said she told the young man, “I only know one guy, a local, that could swim it like this, and he’s in prison.”
Two residents, learning of the concerning situation, quickly rushed to the scene in a motorboat to rescue the two students while almost all the remaining watercraft and their occupants were carried swiftly out of sight by the rising Eel River. “Everyone else got pulled down river,” the onlooker from the bridge told us. “We never seen them again.”
The motorboat driven by a local man faced some difficulties in the swift water but did navigate to the two youth. “He had a hard time with how swift [the river] was,” one of the onlookers told us, “and he has a really large motor.” Two local men aboard the motorboat pulled the kids onto the larger boat’s deck and got their inflatable loose. Eventually, they brought the youth and their watercraft to land.
The locals took the young adult and the two students down to a place called Hippie Hole. “There was better land there,” the onlooker said. “The more experienced [young adult] put them in with him and took them downriver. The young girl was really shaken.”Several members of the community have been very concerned–especially as rain poured down Wednesday.
Diana Totten, a well-known firefighter and rescue person in Southern Humboldt, is staying abreast of the situation though no one really knows where the group is on the Eel. She told us, “The river has come up quite a bit [since the group launched]. The gravel bars are completely covered. The river is bank to bank…The water is muddy and swift. It is dangerous.”
The river has risen six feet since the group’s launch, according to USGS water data.
This afternoon, Donna Sullins told us she received a text from the group leader. The woman asked Sullins to meet her this evening at the confluence of the two Eel Rivers where they had originally agreed that Sullins would leave her vehicle this coming Sunday. “She said there is [an] injury,” Sullins reported. “I texted her back and asked if she needed a ambulance but no response.”
Sullins is currently at the confluence of the Eels McCann hoping that the student group arrives soon.
UPDATE 9:15 p.m.: Supervisor Michelle Bushnell who has spoken to Humboldt County Sheriff Bill Honsal tells us that the school group has not yet been located but that Humboldt County Search and Rescue is on the way to the area as are two US Coast Guard helicopters who will fly the river as long as the weather allows the flight crews access.
UPDATE 9:55 p.m.: According to Supervisor Michelle Bushnell, the school group has been contacted and “they don’t need assistance.” She tells us, “The hurt person was picked up and shuttled out by a third party.”
She added, “They will be out of the river in the early morning.”
A whole county is going to sleep easier tonight.
UPDATE 10:21 p.m.: According to a comment from Humboldt Bay Coast Guard, “For those following: while the USCG aircrew was preparing to launch earlier this evening, we received an update from Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office that the group sent a message indicating they were not in any distress. HCSO was no longer requesting Coast Guard assets and will continue to monitor the situation. Thanks again to HCSO for their coordination!”
UPDATE: The Kids Are Safe!: Students Floating the Swollen Eel River Have Made It Safe to McCann
Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules
Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/
A GPS unit would have been a good thing to take along. Maybe next time. I sure hope everyone makes it to the rendezvous point safely.
Better yet take some common sense along, but hell they are from Bezerkly no common sense there.
😂🤣😂🤣. You are in humboldt county. You think you have room to talk shit? 😂👍
Meaning what? We can talk “shit” if we live here, love it here, and know enough to respect nature and plan outdoor adventures based on the weather and not expect the planet to accommodate US ‘cause we think we’re hot “shit.” Hope that helps.
I’ve lived both places. You must be bagging on Berkeley, which is an especially sophisticated and vibrant place, because it’s a progressive city. Humboldt could be described as full of country bumpkins… especially SoHum. Both places are like anywhere else. Lots of smart people, lots of morons. (Except red states… those are mostly in the latter category). I expect the well-off parents of the private school kids will be pretty pissed-off.
You have that right. It seems we “Bumpkins” know better than to try and navigate the waters this time of year. Bezerkys should navigate somewhere where it’s safe. Maybe a swimming ppol
Please keep us updated on this.
Wow…
This expeditions trip planner should never be allowed anywhere near a group-trip in the outdoors ever again.
This will be a deeply impactful and experience for the students, and they have my strongest wishes of Godspeed.
Again. Adventure planned well in advance. Lots of moving parts. Hard to change plans when faced with bad weather. Groups especially, have got to be ready to be flexible when heading into the Backcountry.
Thank you for indicating exactly what the problem is. It doesn’t matter what the plans are if nature changes the venue suddenly. You simply must recognize when injury and death are too likely and postpone or have an alternative. No excuses! Hotel rooms have TVs and everybody has a hand device for weather and river updates. You are right; have an alternative plan. Winter and Spring are noted for stormy weather and high water. What were they thinking? They weren’t.
BTW, it is apparent that very little planning or research was done or this would not have happened. Same with the beach nerds rescued in the King Range. It is extremely fortunate that nobody was injured or drowned. The “planner” may have had a toxic blend of youth, ego and testosterone. I hope everyone took their lesson well.
The McCann bridge and the low water bridge at Holmes will be deadly strainers for anyone that isn’t very very experienced.
What a bad idea…
Dear God Save these children.
Total insanity. I’m beside myself that anyone would put a group of kids – or anybody – on a remote and raging river. This is one of the most irresponsible things I’ve ever heard of.
Agreed
The river is probably good for boating. Sometimes high water is easier than when it drops. I just feel bad for the kids having to do it and camp in the pouring rain and cold. Jeez today would be nice on the river. The South fork almost seems like more fun than the main stem. Just the thought of a group of Berkeley preppies having to start their poorly timed adventure in front of EVERYBODY in Alderpoint is hilarious, and something I would definitely have avoided!
Hallelujah, they are OK.
Now I can sleep.
Hope they are careful tomorrow, the forks are churning together at the confluence.
Apparently they are still above the McCann, bridge, and the boxcar hole takes a pretty good bend…
I hope the McCann ferryman will be there, to keep an eye on them, as they pass, just in case…
Very bad timing and total disregard for ambient conditions.
I still don’t have the greatest feeling about this whole thing, like someone should have laid eyes on them to make sure that they are really ok, and not just being subjected to someones bad judgement.
If they were supposed to arrive at Dyerville yesterday? The spokesman already has credibility issues, because that didn’t happen.
I hope everything else from here on works out safely for them all.
Something smells fishy to me.
True, everything does smell fishy.
A couple more local heroes! Hope everyone makes it out safe!
What the heck is wrong with people. I can’t even believe these “educators” did this to their students. I pray they survive and make it to the meeting point. At what point is it child endangerment should CPS be involved? Yhe school needs to be held accountable. I don’t care how much money you have you can’t buy a brain with it.
Jack ass city people think they know it all now some kids might pay for their stupidity with their lives.
There are many kinds of disparaging remarks one could be made about jackass hillbillies, too. But why go there?
15 year old kids, inexperienced, in inflatable kayaks ?
Setting out in a flooded river during winter storm conditions ?
Unless they have ‘made it out’… hopefully somebody called the Coast Guard or Sheriff. The Coast Guard helicopter should fly up the river and try to find them before it’s too late.
I was wondering why I hadn’t seen an LE or Coast Guard response…
Maybe they were “stung” by the King Range Beach ingrates who acted like the USCG harshed their mellow by rescuing them in the same storm event. See, the party must go on; the party can’t stop. Devil (or Coasties) take the hindmost. Maybe the USCG needs to be notified by the “trip organizer.” Like, you know, ASK for help. Sorry, just a thought. That would involve responsibility and professionalism.
whirly-birds have gone down in attempted rescues going back to ‘64 flood, locally.
I just re-read the dispatch and the USCG was notified and was going to launch and the TRIP LEADER called it off!??! HCSO is aware and functioning, I guess, I hope.
yup, you can read for yourself, DECLINED the Coasties!
No problemo, dude! Doh!
“TRIP LEADER called it off!??!” were the ‘Leaders Names, Dumb & Dumber???!!!
Better have life jackets and wet/drysuits.
Ran the main (Dos Rios to A.P.) @ 19,300 cfs, Chocolate milk in the trees. It was a no joke run, saw a solid class 5 hole at Kekawaka and Island Mtn was ugly as hell. If you swam either. it would have been a fatal one. That river will EAT you above 10.000 cfs period,
TRUTH!!
Yeah man. I’ve seen those rivers this time of year from a safe distance. Anyone dumb enough to take a bunch of inexperienced children out in inflatable anythings should be investigated for wreckless endangerment. That is completely insane. They had to have hit at least some high level 3’s. I’ll be completely amazed if they all make it out of the river with just one injury. If I was one of their parents, I’d probably strangle the genius that told them they could do it. I’m also surprised the authorities didn’t cancel their expedition after the first rescues.
Wreckless endangerment sounds about right.
It sounds like they just left the kids behind that got into trouble instantly at Alderpoint, to fend for themselves.
Shameful and irresponsible.
Tough love?
The guys from Alderpoint are heros in my book.
They were prepared and deployed quickly to rescue the two that were left behind.
It could have had a very bad outcome without them.
Way to GET ER DONE, Alderpointers, you guys are definitely capable, and I commend you for a job well done.
Props!
Way to represent.
You Rock.
I’m worried. I did a school trip in June. Two canoes had no experienced paddlers. When the wind came up they just wandered back and forth windblown across the river. Three canoes smashed into each other with the lead canoe hung up on a scag. I broke a paddle avoiding a big rock. This was in June when you could easily wade across. Please keep us updated.
Canoes suck. Kayaks all day long. With the right gear.
If canoes are used on the Eel then they should be purpose built deep cut river canoes for better manueverability…but hard kayaks is a much much better choice.
The only inflatables that should be used, unless late summer low flows, are the standard heavy duty inflatable river running boats (similiar to a zodiac) with 5-7people aboard, unless it’s the supply boat with 1 person.
It’s always a good idea to call the local rafting companies before trying to navigate a river you aren’t familiar with. They can set you up with professionals who monitor river conditions and valuable information about which rivers are within a safe level for your group. Definitely not inflatable kayaks on a river that’s flowing at 17k cfs with a bunch of kids who don’t have any experience! Has anyone called the coast guard? They have rafts and are able to swiftwater rescue.
I commend you for raising the alarm, Donna Sullins. What’s the name of the school? Is it possible that the parents aren’t aware of what is going on?
Coast Guard should be out there and Chopper 102, right away if not there. This is a deadly situation. I won’t even say the what we say about the Trinity at this time of year.
Three
The river owns us, it decides to let you in and it decides to let you out
“Copter 102” belongs to CalFire not the Coast Guard!!! I’m not sure what the designator (Call Sign) is for the Coast Guard chopper!!!
Tell them No, Donna.
I got as far as “private school from Berkeley” and i had a really bad feeling about this article.
my heart hurts for the families of these folks..hope they are all found safely..
What is it with out of area people doing incredibly ill advised trips in very inclement conditions? Hope these folks will be O.K. Good luck to that.
Survival shows on television probably.
Who in their right mind would put anyone especially inexperienced kids on the river right now!!??? They clearly do not know what they are doing..please find these kids soon!!!
Praying for their safe return to land.
Absolutely unimaginable. We used to swim across from whitlow.. but we had a good idea of what we were up against. Hope they make it out.
Gosh I remember the river almost destroying lower Myers in like a few hours
To put things into perspective, 2,700 cubic feet of water per second will fill an in-ground backyard swimming pool in one second.
The Eel’s main stem now is 16,800 Cubic Feet per Second.
That’s a lot of water folks, 6.22 in-ground swimming pools per second.
It’s been two days!! Any updates??!!
Shit, I’m very experienced on rafting the eel River. I’ll ride down and find them if everyone else is to afarid! This is bs! Why wasn’t there rescue boats put in the water to find these kids!?!?! Seriously 2 days and no updates?? They are just gone. I have a hard time believing this…
I had 2 friends die like that on the Trinity in the late 70s. Neither had ever rafted before and the river was a record high levels, muddy, and really fast flowing.
What is the name of the school in Berkeley?
Sounds like something Black Pine Circle would get themselves into ..
I did a little google research: Eel River Expedition Berkeley Rose Waldorf SchoolMon Apr 18 – Sun Apr 24, 2022
(7 days)
Wild and scenic and one of Northern California’s hidden gems, the lower Eel River winds its way towards the ocean through coastal prairie, oak woodlands, and redwood forest. Life on expedition is both rhythmic and exciting; it invites us to appreciate routine and adventure, and to realize the strength that lies within community. We will paddle approximately 5-10 miles a day as we travel downstream. Learning to maneuver our inflatable canoes through swift moving water, we will begin to understand the power of the river. Off the water we will create beautiful wilderness homes, swim, and cook delicious meals over fire.
Our journey begins at our Redwood Valley basecamp located at the homestead of our dear friends Luke and Emily Frey in Mendocino County. In 2017, the fall wildfires raged through the property, burning much of the farm infrastructure and personal homes. Along with this devastation however has come incredible resilience and new growth within the community and landscape alike. Here, we will do service work and prepare for our expedition, after which we will drive northwest through scenic country to the Eel River.***SADLY, ANOTHER ONE IS SCHEDULED TO START TOMORROW: Eel River Expedition
Marin Waldorf SchoolSat Apr 23 – Fri Apr 29, 2022
(7 days)
Wild and scenic and one of Northern California’s hidden gems, the lower Eel River winds its way towards the ocean through coastal prairie, oak woodlands, and redwood forest. Life on expedition is both rhythmic and exciting; it invites us to appreciate routine and adventure, and to realize the strength that lies within community. We will paddle approximately 5-10 miles a day as we travel downstream. Learning to maneuver our inflatable canoes through swift moving water, we will begin to understand the power of the river. Off the water we will create beautiful wilderness homes, swim, and cook delicious meals over fire.
Our journey begins at our Redwood Valley basecamp located at the homestead of our dear friends Luke and Emily Frey in Mendocino County. In 2017, the fall wildfires raged through the property, burning much of the farm infrastructure and personal homes. Along with this devastation however has come incredible resilience and new growth within the community and landscape alike. Here, we will do service work and prepare for our expedition, after which we will drive northwest through scenic country to the Eel River.
https://www.linseed.works/forms/activities?key=XM9rmrABiens&view=card
aha! Waldorf, I should have known. Good research!
Looks like they are working with this outfit .. https://kroka.org/about/connection-to-waldorf/
Their slogan is “Where consciousness meets wilderness”. Like a brick to the head sometimes, I suppose.
If they aren’t found by tomorrow I can run to the forks and back from ap I have a boat that can do it if I can get pass McCann.
Thanks. They got found. It’s good to know there are people like you out there.
Anytime, glad they are ok
Nice job everyone! And thanks for the update Kym. Yes indeed, we will all sleep better.
This won’t make me sleep better. What the heck kinda rafting trip is this? Overnight? Can’t help but think of my own children in these elements through the night.
Incredible story. Incredible all or alive.
Years ago my mom wouldn’t let me go tubing down the headwaters of the South Fork river. How Embarrassing it was until the next day My high school buddy’s barely made it out alive.
I thanked my mom for having more sense than me.
If the person who said they aren’t in need of assistance is the same person who decided to force some inexperienced kids from Berkeley to raft down the Eel in April during a storm, I don’t really trust that they are ok. Clearly this adult’s judgement is impaired and the kids are at the mercy of their terrible ideas. Not fair to the kids, this fieldtrip from hell. Maybe it’s some sick pretentious way of building life skills or survival skills or scaring them straight. Either way, it’s traumatic for the kids and psychological abuse. The adult should be charged with child endangerment, or do we wait until one of the kids pays with their life? Next week’s lesson: Negotiating Your Way Out Unharmed After Accidentally Walking Into Gang Turf in Oakland Wearing the Wrong Colors.
It sounded like a great idea last week when it was 90 deg. down there. Oakland, and the Bay never really has “Gang Turf”. None of that colors shit. Tupac was faking it after a trip to LA. Maybe if you’re from Piedmont, or Berkeley hills you should stay out of Acorn projects, and Alderpoint!
It appears that once again, as we saw, again, in the most recent King Range beach rescue, people are apparently refusing to check 7-day weather forecasts before embarking on outdoor expeditions, even though everybody has some sort of hand device that permits exactly that. Apparently, this group’s organizer failed to consider that winter and spring are always higher risk and the highest risk for HIGH water is March through May with winter rain and snowmelt. This information would be available along with river reports from any recognized white-water rafting or kayaking club.
Total incompetence. And this during a record drought. I hope everyone comes through OK and takes the hard, life lesson seriously.
Locally, practically speaking we aren’t in a record drought any more. Maybe the nonstop “Drought” mantra is part of the bad planning for this group. Otherwise CA will be in a “drought” forever because we’ve over allocated irrigation water. A normal or average water year for CA will never cover the southern central valley’s irrigation, and development needs again.
Why the hell is this even a story? Report the news… not your worries or concerns…
no one asked you to read or comment on this publication. You just wasted 5 min of your life you will never get back.
Charges against the parents and adults involved? Who in their right mind would look at the river in real time and look at the weather and predictions and still put an inflatable kayak in and think it’s ok? This must be a planned distraction by the forces that be.
“This must be a planned distraction by the forces that be.”
Hilarious! Sounds like a good plot for a movie: the CIA uses young agents disguised as city kids to continue a river trip in the rain despite locals knowing better, all as a plot to distract the population into reading 5 min longer than usual, as their coffee gets cold… Chilling plot twist!
“This must be a planned distraction by the forces that be.” I think it was just plain Stupidity on the part of the “City People” in charge!!!
Yes
Super dumb “leader” needs to be recused of her duties. Such an idiotic decision! Pouring rain, river float , in April???
Do we need signs at the edge of the county describing the perils in our rivers ,and at the ocean’s edge? I think maybe we do.
And this was a teacher?…. I just can’t anymore with people and their empty brains.
Not a teacher. Kroka Expeditions appears to be selling ” educational field trips” are private schools. Read in the comments – there’s a copy of the field trip description – sounds pretty sweet and certainly not what they’re getting.
I have to wonder if the “adults” who are running this money making venture are in a position to accurately decide whether or not they need assistance. They’re making money off of these kids. They probably would never escaped the civil lawsuits that would follow from having to be rescued, let alone possible criminal charges.
The two locals in the jet boat, straight stallions. The thanks are to them!!
No life jackets. When will we ever learn?
The article said they had Life Jackets, just No Brain Buckets, (Helmets)!!!
the kids had lifejackets. Not the guys operating the powerboat
Agreed.
So after all that, they’re continuing??? Is there anything that can be done to stop them, at least with the children? Anyone notify the parents how extremely dangerous this is??????
‘Kroka Expeditions’ appear to be the incompetent fools that coordinated this trip. Parents be warned.
Thank goodness, this could have been a really horrible ending!! Great news.
I just thank God that none of the kids were killed in that uncalled for adventure. The people in charge of letting these kids get into the river when it is running like that need to punished for their actions. Thank you to the two local men and their boat for bringing the tired kids to shore. You may have possibly saved their lives. Glad all are accounted for and no serious injuries of deaths. Hopefully they will never get into another river that is up, muddy and running fast again.
I suspect part of the problem is these things get scheduled far in advance then on the scheduled time the weather turns to shit. Rather than call off an event in the face of adverse conditions people “go for it”. Then other people have to save their asses.
Life is not a video game and nature bats last. People who live here understand that or at least many of us do.
The lost coast trail should have plaques at both ends saying THIS TRAIL KILLS PEOPLE, BE CAREFUL! Or maybe one that says “If you need to be rescued you will be charged for all expenses incurred.” The Coasties should bill those entitled idiots that they pulled off the lost coast trail!
The folks in that ‘copter that hauled ’em out could have been killed like the crew that hit the cliff at the Cove years ago going to the rescue of folks who’s sailboat hit the reef at Point No Pass. The boat eventually floated off the rocks when the tide came in but the crew of 4 would be rescuers all perished.
Bah Humbug!
It has always surprised me how many people set out hiking, boating whatever, thinking they’re prepared, experienced & believe there’s no need to take any extra precautions like informing someone/anyone of their plans & whereabouts. But lordy, once there’s any sort of mishap, injury or missing persons, this amazing thing starts to form when responders take charge, volunteers being to arrive & each & everyone one of them put themselves at risk to save them & bring them home safely… regardless of gender, race, IQ. It doesn’t matter, these beautiful people pull off the most extreme rescues, across rugged terrain & unimaginable weather conditions, never asking for recognition or hero award. Awesome awesome! I’m sure there’s some underlying wish that afterwards these folks become humble & actually appreciate their life & just ‘do better’ and be ‘worth the trouble’…🥰
This story is almost too absurd to believe. Thank goodness for the locals keeping an eye on this. Those poor kids. At least they have a hell of a story to tell
My child was on this trip and I can confirm that this is fake news. The students had a wonderful trip without danger, risk, or injury.