CDFW to End Hatchery Operations at Mad River Fish Hatchery in Humboldt County

Mad River Hatchery [Image from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW)]
The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) has made the difficult decision to cease hatchery operations at the Mad River Fish Hatchery in Humboldt County.
A combination of increased regulatory burden and a lack of flexibility, aging infrastructure, significant and necessary costly repairs and maintenance, modernization needs, and low fish production and returns forced the decision to close the steelhead trout hatchery just east of Arcata.
“Quite simply, the steelhead program is no longer viable,” said Jason Roberts, Inland Fisheries Program Manager for CDFW’s Northern Region. “The Mad River Fish Hatchery is no longer providing much if any conservation benefit to the species nor the intended recreation or sport fishing benefits in the Mad River. The careful review of these resources indicated they could be better used elsewhere. Our focus now is implementing a transition plan for employees, equipment and resources, repurposing the buildings and making sure the property remains open and accessible for the public to access the Mad River.”
The Mad River Fish Hatchery has been beset by challenges for two decades. In 2004, a state budget crisis forced its closure. The hatchery was able to reopen in 2005 due to community support, but its operations have diminished over time as regulatory demands, operational expenses and infrastructure maintenance needs have increased.
Opened in 1971, the hatchery once raised Chinook salmon, inland salmon and rainbow trout for recreational fishing and steelhead trout to support the native run within the Mad River itself. Over time, all but the steelhead and trout programs have been phased out of hatchery operations.
Today, the Mad River Fish Hatchery is CDFW’s smallest hatchery with three full-time employees, a $730,000 annual budget and a maximum annual steelhead production goal capped by federal fish agencies at 150,000 fish. CDFW’s Trinity River Hatchery by comparison, which also operates a steelhead program to support species conservation and a destination sport fishery, raises and releases about 450,000 steelhead and 4.6 million salmon annually.
CDFW estimates it would need another $1 million annually to continue Mad River Fish Hatchery operations at current levels and likely tens of millions of additional dollars to make needed repairs, modernize the facility for the future and meet federal requirements.
The northern California steelhead found in the Mad River is a federally listed threatened species. As such, the federal government has considerable regulatory authority and oversight of Mad River Fish Hatchery operations, including operational standards that cap production limits in multiple ways and require biological monitoring of impacts to wild populations.
Remaining steelhead in the hatchery will be released into the Mad River in the spring with hatchery operations expected to cease in June.
CDFW plans to maintain a presence at the hatchery facility, repurposing the buildings into offices and continuing to use the workshop. The property will continue to be open from sunrise to sunset to allow public access to the river. The public’s current use of the premises to park and access fishing, hiking, birding and swimming along the Mad River will remain.
The closure of Mad River Fish Hatchery operations will not impact the local stocking of rainbow trout in inland waters for recreational fishing in Humboldt County.
Apart from Mad River, CDFW operates 20 other hatcheries across the state producing millions of fish for conservation and recreation every year. For more information about California’s hatcheries, head to CDFW Fish Hatcheries web page.
Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules
Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/
IMHO: It was a basically a PR (Public Relations) hatchery to begin with. Primarily built to ‘display’ to the public. A ‘real’ hatchery should have been built just below Ruth Dam (like Lewiston), but wouldn’t draw many visitors.
—
Oh well.
Maybe but it certainly was good PR with this member of the public. I found it fascinating.
So did I. In fact, I went there earlier today for a visit, if for the last time. Sure seemed like some concrete fish troughs could be rehabbed for a whole lot less than the million$ they’re claiming.
Hey CDFW,
Before you do anything brash, have you spoken to the Yurok nation about this?
They no doubt would be interested.
!
Wouldn’t that be great?!!! We should just give it to them and also agree to give them an endless supply of money to repair, upgrade, and operate it.
Maybe Mad River Brewery could make it into a hatchery/brewery!
Wasn’t it sold to another band of indians located in the Central Valley ?
Yes, it was. The Paskenta Band took it off the Yurok’s hands in March ’24. I wish they had hung onto it, being more local than its new owners, but I don’t make those decisions.
Maybe not, if they are aware of the diseases, that for years afflicted fish reared in that hatchery.
The concrete runs and associated structures were impregnated with a rot disease that couldn’t be simply flushed out.
Fish coming from the facility were heavily restricted as to where they could be stocked, causing a decline in demand and use of the hatchery.
Thank you two dogs!
This!
I’ve talked to fish and game years ago about the hatcheries in California our local game warden Mathew wells told me it’s there goal to shut down all the hatcheries in California. What a joke let’s just take away every outdoor activity one by one fish and game you suck. FYI wild fish will never make a comeback back with out brood stalk hatchery fish put in rivers it’s science look into Oregons brood stalk program they work 100%
I get the (fair) point that using well water rather than the river water 100 yards away had a negative imprinting on returning fish. Seems that would be an easy fix. I’d also agree that there isn’t enough native fish to sustain the populations all by themselves, so by doing this, it may be the death knell for the locally native stock. I’d go further and say that if you have a fishing boat in northern CA, it might be time to sell now, what with very limited (if any) seasons coming up. It might be better fishing up in Oregon. For a while, anyway.
I agree 100%. My dad was a fish culturist there from 85-98 and for 20 years before that at Feather river fish Hatchery, Mt Shasta fish hatchery and Mount Whiney fish hatchery .Hatcheries had a huge impact on restoring the fish populations. We would see countless fishermen from all over the state visit Mad River fish hatchery for the the fall Salmon runs. It brought many people to the area and was a boon to the local economy. Besides all the opportunity available to all to catch a fish from the river. Then some how the biologist convinced the state that restoring stream habitat would replace hatchery fish with wild ones but surprise surprise the fish never returned at those numbers again when they cut the funding. Now the state has decided to close the hatchery and give it to the tribes. Really, do you think the public would have a vote in this? But of course they never did. Yes it was expensive to operate but it was well worth it. Look at the stupid crap the state spends $ on now. Transitioning inmates. California, this government has lost its way. My dad put his life, heart, and soul into raising the fish for the good of the average fishermen. The people that lived and worked at these hatcheries were all family and believed in aquaculture. It was a way of life. The politics used environmentalist to stop people from fishing the Mad and in there place the druggies and homeless trashed the river banks with needles and garbage. You’ve got to ask yourself if that’s environmentally friendly. Times are changing. We are paying more for fishing licenses every year but is that $ going back to the fishery anymore? You can blame it on global warming or fin rot from the race ways all you want but the sad fact of the matter is you can’t even begin to believe the salmon, steelhead or trout can repopulate the streams,lakes, and ocean if you don’t start raising farmed fish again for all the people who fish. Oregon is proving this theory out as we speak. This state needs to get out of their college indoctrination thinking and back to what we know already worked.
Can’t quit feeding the sealions and otters. They might have to eat things that are harder to catch.
Or easier to catch, like fishermen
Poor management and an employee who trys to act like a gamewarden when he is only an over paid janitor. Place had potential if the employees were more interested in making it work, rather than just collecting a paycheck.
The CDFW is too invested in the Marijuana game now and less interested in wildlife preservation and education.