Hometown: Bad Teeth 1
Linda Stansberry provides a column for Redheaded Blackbelt once per month. If you don’t know this homegrown writer’s work, we’re betting you’ll soon come to look forward to every column. And if you do know, you’ve probably already skipped this intro to get to the good stuff, her writing:
I believe in fluoride. I believe in it because I grew up fifty miles away from the nearest freeway drinking cold, clear springwater and getting high on the cheapest drugs at hand: Off brand soda and Little Debbie snack cakes. There were four of us – my mom, my dad, my brother and I – and our teeth gained holes like a Humboldt County back road in the spring.
It took two hours to get to the dentist in Garberville. Two hours, down a four-mile gravel driveway, then the narrow, pothole-filled county road. Sometimes in the middle of the driving rain. Imagine driving four hours round trip through a winter storm to take your unappreciative children to be tortured by a man with a drill and then paying hundreds of dollars for the privilege. Again, fluoride.
In the way of most middle-class children, I assumed my dad was rich. He wasn’t. We canned fruits and vegetables all summer to eat in the winter. And without any kind of insurance to buffer the cost, he took us to the dentist and paid out the nose to make sure our cavities were filled and our overbites corrected. He did it for the same reason my mother yelled at me when I went barefoot by choice – because they knew what real poverty looked like, and they wanted to give their kids the best chance they could to be healthy and fit in. Now that I’m an adult and I have to pay for my own dental work, I feel like apologizing to my parents all the time for everything I took for granted.
My first dentist was nice – a Vietnam veteran who also umpired for the local softball league. On the rare occasions I made it to third base at away games he would ask me about my fillings. My teeth at twelve were a patched road of fillings. And then came the orthodontist.
I am going to say something controversial again. I think most orthodontic work is a scam. It’s a scam the way that Brazilian waxes are a scam. It’s the infliction of pain for a pointless aesthetic norm. There was nothing wrong with my little overbite and my slightly raised canine teeth, which gave me the appearance of a chubby little fruit bat. But the orthodontist told my mother that my mouth would grow crowded and my bite would be off when I got older, and so began the monthly torture. For those of you that have never worn braces, imagine this: Someone glues a tiny metal square to each of your teeth. Then they wrap a piece of wire around all those those little metal squares and winch it tight, tight, tight, until tears run down your chubby cheeks. Your tongue tries to explore this violation and the orthodontist instructs his hygienist to restrain it with a wooden stick. The only measure of autonomy you have is the color of the rubber bands they wrap your braces with. You try to pick colors that the other kids at school might think are cool. They are never cool.
Our orthodontist was in Fortuna, two hours in the opposite direction of the dentist. Fortuna was a big town compared to where we grew up. It had – check this out – a Burger King and a McDonalds.I tried to make friends with the sophisticated middle-class kids in the lobby, but they looked at me like I was weird. My little brother blushed with shame when the pretty receptionist made him go back outside and wipe the cow shit off of his shoes.
It’s hard to do things in the cold. We had only wood heat when I was growing up and the nights were so cold in the winter it would wake me up at night. Lots of mornings I would take my clothes back to bed and get dressed under the covers. Standing in our icebox of a bathroom and going through the patient motions of threading floss beneath the wires of my braces every night to remove all of the trapped food felt impossible and pointless. I still remember the disappointed tick of my orthodontist’s inhale the day my braces came off.
“You didn’t clean your teeth, did you?” he asked. My now perfectly-straight teeth were flecked with orange and yellow stains. I had pictured the day my braces came off differently, the first stage of my transition from ugly adolescent duckling to lithe teenage swan. Instead, I taught myself to smile with my mouth closed, and I’ve been doing it ever since.
Bad Teeth I is the first installment of a three-part series I’m writing to help bring attention to the need for more comprehensive oral health care in Humboldt County. February is National Children’s Dental Care Month.
Eureka Mayor Susan Seaman, the California Center for Rural Policy at Cal Poly Humboldt and the Dental Advisory Group are looking for your stories about dental challenges in our community. They’ll be hosting a meeting to talk about how to support efforts to increase access to oral health services for all of us who live in Humboldt County. Please visit HumOralHealth.bit.ly for more information.

Linda Stansberry (she/her) is a writer and journalist who lives in Eureka. Hometown is her monthly syndicated column. You can find more of her work at www.lindastansberry.com.
NOTE: After reflection the author requested we update “I think orthodontic work is a scam” to “I think most orthodontic work is a scam.”
Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules
Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/
I know where you are coming from.
Torture is right, and the orthodontist seemed to enjoy every minute of it.
Sadists, as far as I am concerned.
I hate name dropping, but I, I, I, …
??”I”, was his middle initial.?
I bet we had the same orthodontist, but I was pre-glue on, those bands encircled every tooth in my day…
But first, they had to make room…
with, “expanders”, between each
tooth, ouch!
And to make it even roomier, OUT!, at once!, with all my 4 canine teeth in one quick sitting…
The memory etched in my mind…
(A couple of those canine roots weren’t that far away).
I’m to the point now where I wish I had those 4 teeth back, now, but I wish they were “back” teeth, now.
Thanks for the story, Linda Stansberry, I always do enjoy them…
It definitely brought back memories.
Painful memories, but memories, nonetheless.
Look at the cars in the parking lots (the people who work at the orthodontist) that’s all you need to know
AGREED! My orthodontist took 4 of my teeth also. And, I have come to accept that he was just LAZY! I mean, that’s 4 less he has to care for. I will write his name because this happened nearly 40 years ago: Dr. Shukit in Grafton, WI. Disgusting!!
I agree with your comment that orthodontia is a racket…just don’t break your retainers in college and fail to get them repaired. Wear them religiously, or, like me, invest all over again with the plastic ones that cost even more than what your parents paid to straighten them in the first place…sigh!
Jeeze Linda, your story brings me back to my childhood. Our springs lack the natural fluoride that some places in this nation find so prevalent.
I was raised, until I was ten years old, on a ranch in Laytonville. We had no electricity, we had an outhouse, we only had wood heat. My Mom cooked our food on a wood stove. We were fancy ranchers, we had a pump-up Colman white gas lantern for a light.
I had a similar experience with my teeth. I had a terrible time with holes in my teeth, I also have a terrible time with my persistent sweet tooth, my German Grandfather called me a snickle-fritz (sugar-nut). I credit Doctor Ball (The Surfing Dentist) for saving my teeth with, a Fluoride treatment!
I had one front tooth that leaned back and was starting to go behind my front teeth. My Grandmother (American family from Plymouth Rock days) said she knew someone that straightened their own tooth with a stick. She gave me a popsicle stick and told me to pry in forward by prying the tooth over the bottom teeth. I lived with that stupid popsicle stick for about a year… It worked perfectly. I credit Gramma.
I never tried the Brazilian wax job… guess it’s not too late.
That’s an amazing story, about straightening that tooth, Ernie.
That must have taken a lot of perseverance.
Any body else I probably wouldn’t believe, but I know better than to doubt you.
I have witnesses. I probably wasn’t as persistent as I stated but, as soon as I got the tooth in front of the bottom teeth I kept my mouth bit down. Some pain, not bad. The hard part for me, as one might guess, was keeping my mouth shut.
Once again, Ernie’s storytelling runs circles around mine.
Her opinions on orthodontia seem ignorant. Cosmetics matter to an extent, and a good functioning bite is important.
If you haven’t been through it, well, you haven’t been through it.
There was nothing wrong with my “bite”. I just looked like a cave man.
If anything, the orthodontia just screwed my bite up.
TMJ ever since, and pop, pop, pop, when I eat, also ever ever since.
And I still look like a cave man, just one with straight teeth.
And having braces definitely led to shortened roots, and lots of cavities.
Spot on…Her opinion is more than ignorant..
I spend a lot of time thinking about dental myself…
My childhood experience was similar, as sodas were a nickel (3 cent deposit on the bottle), and candy was also a nickel… The first thing I learned, was you could trade discarded soda bottles for soda and candy, and it was all downhill from there…
I suppose learning to make money out of nothing is a skill, but not one I learned to do more than immediate needs demanded…
And dentistry, in the 50’s, was horrifying, fraught with the greed that all professional school graduates seem to be motivated by! I always wondered how many of those fillings were really necessary, and I never worried that my much-restored teeth were going to be a problem… By the time I was 50, I had tooth loss, crowns, inlays, onlays and teeth with many fillings… At some point, I had all the Mercury fillings removed and replaced with composite, since I was developing symptoms of arthritis which, at the time, was supposedly caused by mercury fillings…
Now, at 70, I’m an old dog, losing teeth, bone loss, gum recession, and my siblings and I all discuss the same issue…
My own children, had their teeth brushed, by me, and flossed too! I got the regular “California Teeth” for my kids, and at 18 I told them, if you get a cavity in your perfect teeth that I paid a fortune for, then YOU pay the bill!
The best thing we can teach, is care of teeth, and personal responsibility for our own health…
Dentists, make way more money than they used to, but you can use Listerine and Fluoride almost anywhere…
Damn that Shasta Cola anyway, and all those Hershey bars…
Current dental frustrations include cancellation after cancellation due to Covid that has turned my daughters simple filling into a $2700 root canal my insurance doesn’t cover. The cavity was first discovered in late 2019. The only appt available was during my daughters volleyball game and she begged me to reschedule it. I tried but it was months before another available appointment. Enter Covid. Sorry, we have to cancel your appointment due to Covid. Sorry, we’re not making appointments right now due to Covid. Sorry, we have to cancel your appointment because we can’t do fillings right now due to Covid. Sorry it’s been too long since she’s been seen so now we need to do an exam again at the appointment that you’ve finally managed to get. Sorry, we’re still not gonna fill that cavity because we want to do a cleaning first. Sorry. We have to cancel your appointment because we can’t use air tools right now because of the Covid surge. Sorry, we’re not making filling appointments right now because of Covid. Sorry, we cannot fill that tooth now. It’s going to need a root canal because it’s been too long and it’s gotten worse. Sorry we don’t do root canals. Sorry root canals aren’t covered under your insurance. Sorry there is no payment plan or sliding scale for a root canal. Sorry we only cleaned half of your child’s teeth, you’ll need to make another appointment. So many sorrys and so many disappointments. I understand Covid sucks but there has to be a better way to care for a child’s teeth other than sorry….
Leave not until tomorrow, that which you can do today.
Get the hell out of Humboldt. My dentist never stopped seeing patients during Covid and even sent out a message inviting us to send friends to her, whose dentists had! She cares that much. And she also offers state of the art sonic cleaning. Humboldt is lost. When people ask why I travel to the bay for medical care I ask them if they would travel to Eureka (or Garberville) for theirs. Nope.
My favorite http://m.drdarya.com/
The absolutely pathetic and inferior state of dentistry, and health care more generally, in this backwater county is an outsized factor for people leaving the area. In larger urban areas, plenty of good quality dentistry is available and being delivered during Covid every day.
Just be glad it was a bad tooth and not a bad ankle. She’d be on crutches now. Maybe you should have had her get the ‘vid so she could at least be seen by a doctor for something.
LOL, as usual, I am an exception to the rule, though I’d lay money I had the same orthodontist in Fortuna as you did.
While I suspect braces were in some plan somewhere, I lost my parents before it could happen. Flash forward 20++ years of ‘snaggle teeth’ and after not being able to eat on one side of my mouth for 5 years I finally bit the debt bullet and had it done in my mid 30s. ? $$$ ?
One thing that impressed me is how they never used the word ‘pain’ in that medieval torture chamber where my teeth were put on the rack (not too mention I now have 8 fewer teeth.. what wisdom? And those other extra ones…). I learned to have prehensile lips. Smiling ripped the inside of my cheeks to shreds. Even as an adult I learned your teeth can swim through bone!
But I have to confess, 30++ years later that I can still eat on both sides of my mouth and have lost no further teeth ?
That’s funny, my nickname was “snaggletooth”.
Ok, am I missing something here? “I believe in fluoride”? This statement makes little sense when there are two types of fluoride treatments. One is the polish or topic treatments applied by dentists (or their staff) or pills given to parents. The other is the absurd use of an industrial byproduct in public drinking water which people naively call fluoride. This product is not pharmaceutical grade fluoride and fluoridation is the only example I can think of where medical treatment is administered without dosing based on age, body weight, or other metrics. The fluoride product prior to injection into the water system is labeled as very poisonous on the packaging. Even fluoride toothpaste says to not swallow and if you do call poison control. I am disappointed to read this article and its clear misinformation and conflation of very serious issues.
I’m dismayed by the rank ignorance still being displayed by the fluoride deniers who are the dental equivalent of antivaxxers and Trump insurrectionists. Same ol’ fantasies about toxicity, etc. if you gulp down a heaping tablespoon of table salt (sodium chloride), you’ll get sick. Sprinkle some on a tomato, no problem. Eat too much even that way, you can get blood pressure issues. Dosage is critical. You need sodium chloride.
The true fluoride story is out there, but the deniers prefer doomsday fantasies. Scientists were researching a phenomenon in CO called “brown tooth” where citizens were getting mottled teeth, but very few cavities. Turned out to be fluoride naturally occurring in their water. Adjust the dosage, voila, a public health breakthrough now disparaged by the RFK jr. crowd. No wonder the country’s going to hell. ivermectin is sold out but we can’t give away vaccines.
Wtf are you talking about?
I agree. It’s banned and outlawed in many sophisticated countries because of it’s danger.
To say nothing about the effects flouride has had on our precious bodily fluids…
I got to see my first dentist when I was 13. He was a well-known dentist in Fortuna and he immediately wrote me off as a lost cause. He seemed offended by the 9 or 10 cavities that I had and the teeth out of place. Mostly he seemed offended that my family couldn’t afford to pay him to fix the mess.
I spent thousands over the years to have them filled and crowned and root canaled along with gum surgeries and many courses of penicillin. I endured the pain of infections, extractions, cutting the gums and come to find out, it was mostly genetic. Flossing, brushing, fluoride and sealants could never fix them. An end finally came, and I am extremely happy with dentures. No infections, what a relief! I no longer had to ask dentists if the had gone to the Adolph Eichmann School of Dentistry.
I would love to see dental insurance coverage for anyone who can’t afford it. My single mother struggled to provide food and shelter for me and my two brothers. Limited medical and zero dental care were my family’s daily reality. Yes indeed, I was tortured by chain-smoking dentists (paid for by aunts) wielding teeth grinding machines fashioned with belts and pulleys. As a senior, I am appreciative I can afford state-of-the-art dental care.
Okay what I’m about to say it’s controversial to some but common sense to others. Fluoride probably has more risks to it than rewards. It’s actually kind of simple and easy to keep your mouth clean and cavity free. Just simply by changing your diet and if you do eat any kind of sugary or acidic things always be sure to have water and use it like mouthwash and swish it around push it through your gaps and teeth to get rid of everything. A lot of times people never lose weight working out because they never change their diet. A lot of people get sick easier, die easier, get confused easier and so on all just from poor dieting. Diet is king. Health is wealth. Knowledge is power. I know someone who smokes meth,heroin,weed, and cigarettes and still has perfect white teeth with the only exception of a handful of smaller cavities and he rarely goes to the dentist for anything. I asked how he does it and he told me what I told you basically, also he said he doesn’t eat much sugary things. I don’t know if jeans or certain hereditary things play a role which I imagine they do, but either way what was told to me was learned from trial and error.
definitely his nut tight jeans
What if I said he wears baggy clothes tho?
Hey now easy on the Brazilian waxes.
They are not a scam.
Linda, I agree that in most cases the orthodontic treatment is unnecessary vanity work, which they warn parents must be done to avoid a later “bad bite.” (I’m sure there are a few situations where it really is a good idea, medically warranted, etc. But not most times.)
I had buck teeth, and braces in Jr. High that fixed the problem, after removal of two upper teeth to give the front ones some room to move back. I always wonder if that rabbity, goofy look would have really been so bad. I would have been socially brave and somewhat unique– would have had a distinctive look.
Maybe if i had a little overbite, i would have felt like Joni Mitchell! And been beautiful, talented, and famous, ha!
The blackface pictures would have come back to haunt you when you were trying to supress Joe Rogan’s free speech.
There are ways to get Fluoride other than in drinking water. I do not agree with the belief that drinking water is the best way to get Fluoride into your body. Why put a chemical in our water so we have to bathe in it, our pets have to drink it, and our wounds have to be cleaned with it, etc. Put decent amounts in toothpaste, chewing gum and even in the toothbrushes. Sell home Fluoride treatment kits. Why taint our pure clean water?
I grew up with fluoride, my son did not. I have fillings in all my molars though my last filling was done over 60 years ago. My son has perfect, straight healthy teeth and not a single cavity at the age of 51. He does have a capped tooth, the result of a bicycle crash when he was 9. You never can tell.
I needed to have various ‘extraneous’ teeth extracted, and wore braces (and had to wear a special jaw ‘reconstruction’ head brace, every night, overnight) for 3 years. Retainer for 2 years after that. Zero cavities when my braces were finally removed. On the South Island of New Zealand, too. Looking after your teeth was a big deal, unless you really wanted to swim over to Oz for better (more expensive) treatment options. I did end up with a permanently injured shoulder, prone to ongoing dislocation, b/c a dentist leaned on my shoulder too awkwardly while trying to restrain me during a routine dental exam as a child. But, you can’t sue for damages there, like you can here. ‘Some’ people place far too much weight on cosmetics, at the expense of long-term oral health and preventive care. My teen daughter now gets her dental care in Western Nebraska, after an horrendous ‘root canal’ experience, here. It’s worth the plane ticket, imo.
Thanks for this great series. My family has had struggles with dental care here in Humboldt and I once got all my front teeth capped via a trade of goods for services:) That was a one off and I am sure never again LOL