Mountain Musings: On Experience… and Mistakes

Mountain Musings – A guest column by Dottie Simmons who lives in eastern Humboldt County describes life at her rural homestead:
Musing on Experience… and mistakes
Someone once said “Good Judgment depends mostly on experience and experience usually comes from poor judgment.” Well, I certainly agree with that!
I don’t think I can claim to be an actual ‘expert’ at much of anything. I know what I know, but I doubt I know the actual “best” way to do anything. What I do know is a lot of ways NOT to do things! We have certainly made a lot of mistakes and also done things that worked… sort of. All of this is a great way to improve one’s game.
One of the things I have learned here in Humboldt is its variety of elevations and geology and weather and more influence almost everything we do. Even in things like gardening or cooking, there are always a lot of variables. The gardening tricks we learned in Willow Creek, even at the same elevation, don’t all work here in Dinsmore.
I can tell you why you shouldn’t try to speed chill a bottle of carbonated beverage in a freezer (have you ever seen a freezer completely full of ‘snow cone’?) and why it’s important to consciously put down any sharp tool you are not using at the time while doing something like tree pruning.
Hopefully we all know not to open or try to quickly release any pressure cooking device while it is still under pressure. And that cooking time and results change at different elevations and in different weather.
One learns quickly that wilting plants are not always a sign of too little water. Most die faster from overwatering than underwatering… in fact, most plants hate having their roots wet all the time. And thus hate clay soil. And that clay will overtake all the mulch and amendments you put on it if you don’t keep it up every year.
We’ve learned that protecting hens from hawks with a chicken wire roof can become a disaster in winter and mulch right up to the base of plants or trees can provide cover for rodents.
We learned building an island for ducks doesn’t protect them from otters, bears will climb – or go right through – deer fence, foxes can climb trees, a sheep or goat that simply vanishes was taken by a big cat, and electric fence does more to stop everything than most other deterrents.
Every year we find we are never too old to make new mistakes or learn new solutions. We ‘old dogs’ keep learning new tricks!
But most of all I have learned what works for us may be different somewhere else and I can tell you what works for me, but chances are it will be a bit different for you. Which pretty much limits my *expertise* to my own turf.
But you might be ok calling me an expert in how *not* to do any number of things!

Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules
Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/
Sadly trees that need pollinators that were in sync blooming at sea level may totally be out of sync in the mountains. I replanted my favorite Asian pear more than thirty years ago and have given up on finding it a pollinator that blooms at the same time here.
Yabut,
What variety is your Asian pear tree…???
Have you tried a Bartlett pear tree for pollinating your favorite Asian pear…???
Sometimes that works, depending on the variety of Asian pear…
Putting a few blooming cut branches from a Bartlett pear in water near your tree might be a worthwhile experiment…
Yes. Sometimes it matches sometimes-about once every three years or so- but sometimes it doesn’t. At best it catches the last blooms of the Asian. I wish I could remember the name of the Asian pear but it was a grafting I did off a much older tree and I just can’t. I have checked the characteristics against named varieties but no success. Why record keeping should never be brushed off.
Bartlett was my last try. Considering I’m not fond of them and resent giving space to it just to be a pollinators. But thanks for your post. Bartlett was the closest I ever came.
Interesting…
What is your elevation..???
Did the Bartlett pear bloom too early or too late…???
Wait I just re read your post, and it sounds like you need an earlier Bartlett pear variety than well Regular Bartlett..
I have a Red Bartlett that is blooming hard, in full blossom, right now, and my regular Bartlett pear trees are just getting started blooming.
I am at about 2600’…
Is your Asian pear still blooming…???
Has it ever fruited..???
If not,
Maybe its not an Asian pear tree, or even a pear tree, at all…???
Is it super late hanging and super large..???
Maybe it’s a actually a quince…???
I know of a couple of very late hanging pear like fruit trees that I thought were winter pears, or even Asian pears, but they bear so infrequently and hang so late when they do, that all of the leaves drop, before the fruit drops, and the fruit stays excellent.
I think now that they may actually be quince…
Some varieties of quince can be eaten fresh…
But they can’t be pollinated by anything but quince…
The two trees that I am talking about I’ve only seen bear fruit twice, and once it only produce two or three fruits…
Don’t give up…
I like Bartlett pears, but they have to be all picked green, as soon as the first green fruits drop, and then they must be ideally refrigerated and ripened carefully in a controlled way, in paper or cardboard, in a fairly cool spot…
If they ripen on the tree, it ruins them…
If they get too hot for too long, in storage, like in a hot home, they will ripen and spoil very quickly…
As you probably well know…
What do you know…???
will a red bartlett tree pollinate some asian pears
Red Bartlett Pear | Johnson’s Nursery | KB
Yes, a Red Bartlett pear tree can act as an excellent pollinator for many Asian pear varieties, provided their bloom times overlap. Red Bartlett blooms mid-season, making it compatible with most early-to-mid-season blooming Asian pears (like Shinseiki or Hosui) to produce a consistent fruit crop.
How it Works: While Asian pears often pollinate each other, a European pear like Bartlett (or Red Bartlett) provides the necessary cross-pollination for higher yields.
Compatibility: Bartlett pears are generally considered one of the best “universal” pollinators for many Asian pear varieties.
Requirements: To ensure success, plant the trees within 50 feet of each other to allow bees to transfer pollen effectively, according to YouTube video.
The Asian just ended , the barlett is still in bud.
At 2500’ our lone Asian Pear (kikisui variety, I think) blooms the same time as our d’Anjou… our red & green Bartletts are just starting to bloom. We get a good crop of Asian Pears every year if the bear doesn’t get them first!
Part of my problem i think is that I live in an area more damp and shaded than higher elevations. I’m still in the redwood -salal forest rather than the somewhat higher dryer mixed woods. The Bartlett fruit is riddled with scab although the leaves look fine. When I do get some asian pear, it is fine too. None of the apples get it. The dilemma is a resistant pear that can pollinate.
So the Bartlett is only a pollinator. I have a D’Anjou but it blooms much later.
I live this, Dottie! So many things I still have to learn not to do!
Yup that is the plain truth.
Aaaah, must be the lovely Simmonsville.
When I think back on various endeavors in my life, those things I have learned that proved most solidly helpful tended to come about by observing people do them the wrong way. It then became a simple case of don’t do that.
Ah but there are so many different ways to do something wrong and so few to do it right. I never found it that simple.
Maybe it’s not a simple case after all. Maybe I am skewing the analogy with the benefit of hindsight. But seeing the wrong way play out before me always seemed to be a strong lesson in how not to proceed.
Agreed… Not simple at all.
I find in doing many tasks there are ways that are wrong, ways that work, and ways that work better than others. Some only work under certain circumstances!
Still, I am mainly unwilling to say I know the “best” way to do things in general 😉.
the response usually starts with “what works for me is…”