When DOGE Cut AmeriCorps Positions Locally, Local Agencies and Members Refused to Give Up

Landscaping crew

Ashley Farrington’s AmeriCorps NCCC Team Red 1 were in Trinity County when they learned their Americorps work was terminated. [Image of the team at one of their jobs from their GoFundMe that allowed them to come back to the West Coast and finish with their planned work for BLM on the Lost Coast]

When the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) abruptly terminated several AmeriCorps programs late in April, hundreds of AmeriCorps members across California—including many in Humboldt, Mendocino, and Trinity counties—were left without jobs, clear guidance, and, in a few cases, a place to live. But in the face of uncertainty, local agencies and determined volunteers are finding ways to continue serving their communities.

An email from Regina Wong, Project Manager at the California Capital Center, broke the news to some members at 7:31 p.m. on Sunday, April 27. “This means service must be discontinued effective immediately. This means you should NOT report to your sites on Monday, April 28, 2025,” the email read. It marked a sudden end for programs like Birth & Beyond, Prevent Abuse Through Home Visitation, and the Foster Youth Initiative, which provide critical support to vulnerable families.

Ashley Farrington’s team was working out of cell phone service in a remote area of Trinity County when DOGE’s cuts hit. “[W]e had been clearing out campsites,” she explained describing the team’s work removing invasive plants, repairing trails, and clearing campsites.

The group’s housing arrangements and daily life were deeply intertwined with their AmeriCorps positions. Their tents were provided as part of the job, and their vehicles which carried their tools and personal belongings were assigned through the program.

They were forced to pack up camp, abandon their work, and return to Sacramento to turn in government equipment and paperwork. Within 48 hours, many were on flights home, leaving their temporary homes and their tight-knit community behind.

“It was a very quick turnaround,” Farrington said. For some, it was more than a logistical challenge; it meant losing not just a job but also the place they were living, their sense of purpose, and their community—all at once.

“It was a big switch-up,” she reflected. The team’s work had given them a sense of stability, camaraderie, and a chance to make a difference. The sudden loss of all of that—without warning—left them feeling stranded. “Luckily,” she told us, “I do have my parents to fall back on, where I could go and stay but I know some of my friends, they kind of had to scramble to start calling people to be like, ‘Can I stay with you? I’m coming home.'”

Even for those who had their own apartments, the abrupt termination was rough. “It was just devastating,” said Lauren Beaman, a case manager at the McKinleyville Family Resource Center who found herself abruptly unemployed despite her ongoing caseload. “I went in [to work the next day] anyways,” she said, describing the personal relationships and trust she had built with clients over months of service. “I met with some clients…that I’m in the middle of working on stuff with, so I didn’t want to not meet with them. Some of them I’ve been working with for over a year, and I know that they would be really devastated to just lose that relationship.”

She described the profound impact of her work with local residents: “Some of my clients, I’ll never forget, like they’re people that I grew to really love, and they’re people that came in and they were struggling, and now they’re helped,” she said. “One client [I] helped leave a domestic violence situation and moved to another state. I helped another client through a really ugly divorce… And… clients that I have [helped with] them overcoming  addiction, they’re still coming in, and they have a long-term relationships with this center… .”

Man at a computer

Kyle Groben in Blue Lake in a photo snapped by Senior Club member Jackie Ginn, aunt of this reporter.

For AmeriCorps member Kyle Groben, who served through the AFACTR program, the news was a gut punch personally as he struggled to figure out how to deal with his own finances and it was painful because he worried about those he was working with. “I was helping people out with submitting tax forms and helping people out with legal paperwork and getting them referred to legal services throughout county,” he said. Groben’s role also included identifying people who could benefit from programs like CalWORKs and CalFresh, and helping them get signed up. “I’d make sure they had what they needed,” he explained.

Groben also worked helping distribute supplies for Food for People and at the Blue Lake Senior Center.  “It’s whoever comes in the door, and you figure out what they need and how you can help them out,” he said.

He noted that AmeriCorps workers were spread throughout Humboldt County and their services were lost to the communities: “There was four scattered across Eureka, one in McKinleyville, one in Bridgeville, one in Redway/Garberville” and other areas that he didn’t name.

For Lorey Keele, Community Services Director at Redwood Community Action Agency, the cuts highlight a deeper challenge. “AmeriCorps members have always been essential, helping families with everything from food distribution to transportation to navigating social services,” Keele explained.

The work done by AmeriCorps in Humboldt County has been vital in addressing some of the highest rates of reported child abuse in the state. “We’re second or third in California in terms of child abuse cases,” Keele believes. “AmeriCorps has been a crucial partner in keeping kids and families out of that system and giving them the support they need before things get worse…Losing them hits hard, but we’re committed to filling that gap however we can.”

Locally, the loss of AmeriCorps members hit hard, but the response was helpful. “Initially I was really angry… and devastated,” said Lauren Beaman, an AmeriCorps case manager at the McKinleyville Family Resource Center. “The very next day, Taffy Stockton…was on it, and she was organizing, and I know that all the executive directors from all the family resource centers came together to fight for their AmeriCorps…. I’m grateful that the community cares about us, and I felt really loved and cared about.”

In Southern Humboldt, the shockwaves reached the Family Resource Center in Redway. But local agencies rallied not just there but all around the County. Amy Terrones, Southern Humboldt Family Resource Center Coordinator explained, “Within 24 hours of the cut, Redwood Community Action Agency and Child Welfare Services signed an agreement to reinstate AmeriCorps members using local funds.” Five of the nine AmeriCorps members who had previously worked in Humboldt for local agencies chose to stay on. Others had already accepted other opportunities by the time the agreements were solidified.

Meanwhile, for Ashley Farrington’s AmeriCorps conservation crew, the work felt too important to walk away from and they were excited about seeing remote areas of Humboldt County. She said the crew wanted “the experience of seeing the place that everybody was really hyping up around, how beautiful it was.”

She and four of her teammates organized a return as volunteers for BLM, using a GoFundMe campaign to cover travel and food while they continued their trail maintenance and conservation work on the rugged Lost Coast. Her team’s fundraiser raised more than enough to cover their flights and basic expenses and they were set to come to the Lost Coast in early June to continue trail maintenance and conservation work. “[W]e had committed these few months left—like now we have nothing to do, so why not take the opportunity to try and keep volunteering?” she explained.

Although DOGE’s terminations have disrupted many lives—and forced local agencies to scramble for funding—the determination of both AmeriCorps members and local organizations is clear. Whether by volunteering, finding alternative funding, or forging new partnerships, many folks are determined not to let vital services disappear.

The impact of AmeriCorps goes beyond staffing. “Some of my clients, I’ll never forget,” said Beaman. “I’ve helped people leave domestic violence, navigate divorces, and overcome addiction. These are life-changing services, and AmeriCorps gave me the tools and the support to do that work.”

Amy Terrones, Community Resources Director at the Southern Humboldt Community Health Care District, emphasized that while AmeriCorps’ abrupt exit was painful, local agencies quickly scrambled to keep key positions. “Redwood Community Action Agency and Child Welfare Services signed a contract and an MOU to reinstate AmeriCorps members using local funding,” she said. “Five of the nine members in Humboldt chose to stay on. It felt like there was a lot of positivity and collaboration despite the sudden loss.”

Terrones remains optimistic. “I like the AmeriCorps programs for so many reasons, but I’m optimistic we’ll find a way to continue,” she said. “Our ultimate goal is to provide services to the community. I think we’ll be able to make that happen, even if it means restructuring how we do things.”

Lorey Keele, Community Services Director at Redwood Community Action Agency, underscored the scale of the challenge. “For years, we’ve had anywhere from nine to a dozen AmeriCorps members each year. They’ve been essential in distributing food, helping families get CalFresh, finding housing, and supporting seniors,” she explained. “When DOGE pulled the plug, it threatened so many of those connections.”

But Keele said the local agencies are working hard to bridge the gap. “We’ve been able to squeak out a little money from other sources to keep some positions going until the end of June,” she said. “Our AmeriCorps members are so well-trained and dedicated that many of them found jobs within the first week of the cut. They’re that good.”

The broader impact of DOGE’s cuts is being felt statewide. “I read an article that said they were going after more than 400 agencies, and AmeriCorps was one of them,” Beaman said. “The Heritage Foundation has been trying to get rid of AmeriCorps since it started. They see it as a waste of money. But here in Humboldt, we know how essential it is.”

The future of AmeriCorps in Humboldt County remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: local organizations and volunteers are determined to continue serving the community. As Keele said, AmeriCorps members have been essential to making local programs work. She told us that they have “been able to provide additional service…to family resource centers by helping distribute food bags and food stuff to people who were low income, to helping to get elderly people to and from their doctor’s appointment, helping people find a house and helping people find jobs, helping people…create job descriptions and resumes.”

Even in the face of federal cuts, that commitment endures.

Facebooktwitterpinterestmail

Join the discussion! For rules visit: https://kymkemp.com/commenting-rules

Comments system how-to: https://wpdiscuz.com/community/postid/10599/

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

54 Please improve the conversation by disagreeing thoughtfully and backing your claims with facts
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
The Covelo Way
Guest
The Covelo Way
1 year ago

In my opinion Americorps is not an efficient use of tax dollars. Not a complete waste but mostly a waste.
I’m sure nobody will agree with me.
The list of things they do is laughable.
Like why would our tax dollars be paying to help someone with their divorce? That’s just not ok.

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago
Reply to  The Covelo Way
Kay
Guest
Kay
1 year ago
Reply to  The Covelo Way

The variety of AmeriCorps programs is diverse, the AFACTR (Assisting Families Access Change Through Resources) AmeriCorps program is mostly Social Work graduates that assist Family Resource Centers throughout Humboldt County. This particular one was designed to help prevent child abuse by helping challenged families, in poverty, to have access to basic needs. They have 30-40 hour work weeks, receive ongoing training and are paid a monthly stipend, which used to be $920 a month for approximately 10 months. Which is not a lot, i know because I lived off of this stipend, although I was in a different AmeriCorps at the time, we were all paid the same. I’m sure this amount has changed a little because I’ve been out of the loop for a few years, but let me tell you, it wasn’t a lot. Then, after AmeriCorps, most of these individuals go on to their careers helping people. The experience of AmeriCorps. I think investing in this type of experience, after grad school, was invaluable to determine the path of your career. It is a loss to not have these programs.

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago

its rough out there. Even the middle man/woman is feeling the pinch.

Al L Ivesmatr
Guest
Al L Ivesmatr
1 year ago

The local government agencies should have been responsible for all these activities to begin with.Better yet, local churches and organizations already do much of this work for free out of kindness. The Democrats who were in charge 4 years ago are Wiley in that they know once big momma starts funding anything, it becomes permanent or can be used as a cudgel to batter those who cut waste, fraud,and abuse. That’s their real motive, any other benefits to them are just the icing. Hence, an article like this complaining how it just isn’t fair. Life isn’t fair, ask the child slave in the Congo digging for Cobalt so [edit] in the West can drive their Prius and proclaim they are saving the planet. Perhaps our great political elders who think 1984 should be implemented in all aspects of civilian life should send their own kids over to Africa to dig up rare earth minerals for daily room and board. We shall call it Mining to Save the Planet while learning how the “plebes” live. Survivor for the Upper Crusties edition.

Last edited 1 year ago
Duh
Guest
Duh
1 year ago
Reply to  Al L Ivesmatr

However, we’re the United States of America, not the Congo. You’re comparing apples to oranges. Telling people to get over it because people under authoritarian rule in other countries have it hard, is so cliche. 🤦

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  Duh

And in order for the USA not to spiral into the authoritarian grip of a place like Congo, the founders created a Republican form of government where People, local communities and states were supposed to be in control of their own destiny. Not bureaucrats in DC.

Al L Ivesmatr
Guest
Al L Ivesmatr
1 year ago
Reply to  Duh

Not at all if you consider we are all humans. I am comparing humans in America and the Congo. And why certain humans in America are cool with slave made batteries while denouncing those opposed as racist troglodytes who are killing the Earth. It’s a diversion and total scam. It makes no logical sense and needs to be called out front and center. Valencia oranges to blood oranges, they are one in the same, Same Genus and Species, different variety, different location. Humans. Like I said, it’s time to send Biden’s and Pelosi grandkiddies to the Congo so they get a two by four awakening to the reality of the situation. Otherwise, it’s just gonna continue with an ignorant blob of followers who clap like seals and take it up the …….and want more.

Wasn’t me…it was the dog
Guest
Wasn’t me…it was the dog
1 year ago

Is this county supposed to feel sympathy? Does anyone realize what just happened to this place? Oh no! The people voted on something and then the government destroyed your industry? You don’t say? Well come join the masses toots. This place is an economic dead zone because of local government policy and the way people here vote. Get used to it. Get a real job, as so many of us were told, too bad the income from our jobs that weren’t real were the only thing supporting everyone else’s “real” jobs.

Humboldt Love
Guest
Humboldt Love
1 year ago

Such fine human beings!! Thank you all so much for the important work you do and your top-notch integrity!

James
Guest
James
1 year ago

A salient point in the discussion is from above, “our ultimate goal is to provide services to the community. I think we’ll be able to make that happen, even if it means restructuring how we do things”
Folks bemoan inefficient use of tax dollars. A point driven home by a billionaire who doesn’t even know how to hold a chain saw. Musk is a junky who wants to add $2 trillion to the debt. Smile and wave boys. Smile and wave.
Meanwhile the folks pictured above are in OUR community, they understand how to hold a chain saw lol.

old guy
Guest
old guy
1 year ago
Reply to  James

the mass amount of siphoned off funding and waste in the ‘corps’ doesn’t bother you ?

james
Guest
james
1 year ago
Reply to  old guy

Fox News that says that? Consider the source.

Tangled Massocells
Guest
Tangled Massocells
1 year ago
Reply to  James

“Socialism is great… until you run outta other people’s money.” Somebody said that!

2knucks
Guest
2knucks
1 year ago

Margaret Thatcher

james
Guest
james
1 year ago
Reply to  2knucks

Yep. Consider the source.

Korina42
Member
1 year ago

So if you’re house catches fire you’d be okay with the fire department running your credit card before they’ll come?

socialism-v-capitalism
Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  James

Great. Community is where the funding should come from rather than begging big daddy federal government for money. Local markets create local solutions. Not federal bureaucrats.

suspence
Guest
suspence
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

but a huge portion of my pay check goes to the Feds. Some of that should come back to my community. that creates a positive feedback loop, instead of it going to some huge arms manufacturer, or a industrial farmer in the Midwest (ag bill), etc.

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  suspence

It’s a negative feedback loop as you get diminishing returns when more and more administrators take their cut before actual work is done… hence the $35 Trillion of debt.

james
Guest
james
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

Meanwhile your boy wants to add north of two trillion more dollars in debt. Trillion with a T. As it is, we pay more for interest on the debt every year than we pay the military every year.

Dot
Member
Dot
1 year ago

Thank you to these folks for their dedication and the important work they have been doing.

We often hear complaints when campgrounds and trails are not maintained or other background services are unavailable that often go unnoticed. Or about the difficulty of navigating minor legal paper work, finding housing, and other issues of service to the community. Including helping individuals in times if family crisis. These are things that would otherwise cost the community… and taxpayers… much more to mitigate the need or repair the result of ignoring the issues.
…Might just be the things you don’t realize are needed until you need them yourself.
And, on top of that, an efficient platform for training people in jobs and working protocols that helps them succeed in the work force for their future.

Wishing all these folks the best going forward.

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago

Nicely written Kym. This program cut was one of the more egregious examples of cost-cutting stupidity by DOGE. And it will have negative local on the ground impacts for years.

Mr. Clark
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

And that is GOOD!

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago
Reply to  Mr. Clark

What exactly do you think is good? Stupidity? Or the negative local impacts on the ground?

james
Guest
james
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

These guys are trolls that agree with the overlords that cruelty is the point. Pay them no mind.

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago

A government big enough to give you everything is a government big enough to take everything away.

suspence
Guest
suspence
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

These young ppl are working to improve our public lands, for the public good. where is the give away? I’m paying huge percentage of my paycheck to the feds, some of that is supposed to support public lands for my benefit. Plus our roads, public education, the list goes on. People in your camp have a HUGE blind spot, it’s a very narrow minded perspective.

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  suspence

Public lands have agencies to take care of the lands already. There does not need to be another bureaucracy to make things even more inefficient.

All taxation is theft and we should all pay less to the federal government. Sending money to DC in hopes that a portion gets sent back for local use is foolish.

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

Spoken like a true libertarian.

“Libertarians are like house cats: absolutely convinced of their fierce independence while utterly dependent on a system they don’t appreciate or understand.” (Unknown).

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

It appears you have Stockholm syndrome.

Mr. Clark
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

Look up TDS.

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  Mr. Clark

A lot of pro-Trump people have Stockholm Syndrome as well and think big daddy government will save us.

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

No, I’m one of those people who wishes there was no need for government but who also realizes just how fast most of us would get fucked over if an institution wasn’t in place to rein in the worst impulses of some. Does the government overstep at times? Certainly, it’s run by people and we’re fallible. But the libertarian utopia would quickly become a corporate dystopia if they were left unchecked.

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

Tell me which of the marvelous government agencies aren’t captured by corporate interests or corporate boards not manned by former government overlords?

The Administrative State has convinced you that you need them to be safe and you’ve taken the propaganda as gospel.

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

How much air and water pollution do you think you’d be dealing with in the absence of any regulation or enforcement? How big do you think the clearcuts would be on the hills above your land? How much would the tolls be to travel the roads? How many deaths on the highways if no one enforced limits on speeding or drinking? How soon would indentured servitude or outright slavery become commonplace?

I actually agree that there’s far too much corporate influence on government actions and at least part of that is from the Citizens United ruling. But just because government isn’t perfect doesn’t mean we should dismantle it entirely. Instead we try to fix what’s broken.

The Americorps program wasn’t broken, it was one of the things that actually seemed to work well. The reason it was gutted was because someone at the Heritage Foundation hated it for some unfathomable reason.

Last edited 1 year ago
Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

Cutting funding to AmeriCorp is hardly dismantling the government in any sense.

Every single problem you mentioned is handled locally. These aren’t issues for the federal government. They are issues for communities.

BTW, the best stretch of highway I’ve ever traveled on was a privately administered toll road. I’d much rather pay for the roads I use than pay extortion fees to the DMV and hope they put money into the roads.

Tim
Guest
Tim
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

None of those problems were handled locally. Have you not read any history?

Cutting Americorp is dismantling government in the sense that it cuts valuable service that the program was accomplishing. There are no doubt areas within the government that can be improved. Eliminating Americorp wasn’t an improvement.

Ullr Rover
Guest
Ullr Rover
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

It’s weird considering everything you listed is under state control not federal control.

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

Indentured servitude is probably the best definition of the relationship between the government and the people it claims to work for.

not sure about where you get paid from , but taxation is getting a little hard to swallow these days

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

have you looked around lately?

the system has been punking every single person who trades their time for a taxable income.

slavery never ended.

just rebranded and repackaged

unfortunately, we need people who still believe in the illusion to keep the parasitic system in place.

one book for you to read, or learn about.

“one nation under blackmail” by Whitney Webb

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago
Reply to  Ullr Rover

It’s obvious to the critical thinkers who has been conquered.

Tangled Massocells
Guest
Tangled Massocells
1 year ago
Reply to  Tim

“Utterly dependent on a system they don’t … understand”. My favorite part of the article was when they were headed back to live in “their parents” house. You know… “fierce independence” while utterly dependent. Young person formerly working for this bunch: Mom I lost my job. Mom: Get another job so you can pay for your own place.

Tangled Massocells
Guest
Tangled Massocells
1 year ago
Reply to  Kym Kemp

Been there and done that… meaning job unexpectedly terminated and I had to get on it to keep from living in my van. Moving back in with mom and dad wasn’t even on the radar. Later when they were much older and had memory issues etc., I moved them in with me and worked hard to keep as much of their independence intact – as much as heaven would allow.

Tangled Massocells
Guest
Tangled Massocells
1 year ago
Reply to  suspence

Yeah … roads and public education. Doah!!!! Like 8-10 lane freeways and roads of a thousand holes. Public Education? Now there’s a shining example!

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago
Reply to  suspence

“I’m paying a huge percentage on my paycheck to the feds”

im not sure you have any place to talk about “Huge Blind Spots”

is there a rational conversation to be had about the nature of the tax system that no longer works for us!?

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago

can we look ourselves in the mirror and tell ourselves that workin 3.5 months of the year to pay taxes to get generations of government employees to put this nation into a very dangerous debt crisis is a logical rational thought process!?

we’ve been psychologically overwhelmed with the burden of funding foreign bloodshed in our name.

we try to defend the normalization of the method to those people who try to wake us up from mental slavery.

there is blood on all of our hands.

some of us are just honest about it.

Al L Ivesmatr
Guest
Al L Ivesmatr
1 year ago

Wake us up from mental slavery, “only ourselves can free our minds.” BM, Lion of Judah, Soldjah of Zion. prophet, legend.

D'Tucker Jebs
Member
1 year ago

AP is reporting that a judge has granted a temporary block on the cancellation of AmeriCorps grants. https://apnews.com/article/americorps-trump-doge-lawsuit-f88fb92ffb93dbb5a942f8570412ba3f
Hopefully this includes the positions discussed in this article.
Even if this does restore funding, there’s no doubt that the Trump Administrations short-sighted and poorly thought out actions have caused significant disruptions to services and unnecessary stress and harm to the people who provide and rely upon these services.

Steve
Guest
Steve
1 year ago

A couple of months back, the federal budget anyasis is that payroll is about 4% for the federal budget. Other than defense, payouts to coal, oil,and gas companies stand out.
Each year the IRS only received 60-70% on what is owed.
Senate and Congressional pork-barrel is very high.

willow creeker
Member
1 year ago

Yeah, I think I speak for most people around here when I say ‘FUCK DOGE’

Thought Prophet
Guest
Thought Prophet
1 year ago
Reply to  willow creeker

Anger is good.
Anger is one the fundamental human traits that can bring changes into an individual’s ability to recognize the humiliation for not understanding, and therefore any inability to enforce the concept of limited government as laid out in the founding of our “REPUBLIC”.

ANGER 🙁

This is what normal people feel…. when they’ve been lied to their entire lives about the social contract THEYVE NEVER BOTHERED TO READ

you keep letting bullies steal your lunch money, they will eventually grow up and teach their children, family and friends and associates that stealing lunch money is a family tradition, and pretty soon they hire more of their friends with your stolen lunch money to enforce their program.

so while you say FUCK DOGE, you still hand over your lunch money.

does this make sense!?

https://missingmoney.solari.com/

Yabut
Guest
Yabut
1 year ago
Reply to  willow creeker

Only because, while it saw gross waste, malfeasance and failure, it apparently only was able to spread more misery yet not fix the any of the problems that justify the attempt. Too many folks too invested in demanding self-aggrandizement.

The political catch phrase at one point was ” Ask not what your country can do for you but what you can do for your country.” Sixty years later it has turned into constant demands, blaming and constant carping. It has become “demand government action but not so it inconveniences. “