Defendant Who Shot Marijuana-Taking Debt Collectors Sentenced to 11 Years


Emergency personnel the night of the homicide. [Photo by Oliver Cory]

Press release from the District Attorney’s Office:

Today, Derek Charles Payton was sentenced to eleven years in prison for voluntary manslaughter and assault with a deadly weapon for crimes he committed on October 24, 2015 near the defendant’s residence in the 400 block of Watson Street in Eureka. The victims, Elliott Walin and Nickolas Deremer, went to the defendant’s home with a third man to collect on a debt related to a previous drug deal. An argument occurred inside the house and the visitors grabbed some marijuana before leaving. At that point Payton pursued and shot at the three men. Mr. Walin was struck once and collapsed at the scene. He was taken by ambulance to St. Joseph’s hospital where he was pronounced dead. Mr. Deremer left the immediate area and subsequently sought treatment at a local hospital for a gunshot wound to his shoulder. 

The surviving witnesses were uncooperative with investigators. Using other resources, the Eureka Police identified Mr. Payton as a suspect; he was arrested a few days later and admitted to the shootings.

The victim’s family, and the Eureka Police Department, were included in settlement discussions before the guilty pleas were entered.

Today at sentencing, several members of Elliot Walin’s family were present, including his mother, two sisters, his son, and wife. Victim-impact statements in the form of letters, were submitted to Judge Miles before court and she considered those statements. The wife of Elliot Walin also spoke during the sentencing and she pointed out that Mr. Payton will be able to speak with, and see, his family but that her son is “never going to see his Dad again.” The defendant apologized for his crimes and said, “I wish every day that it had never happened.”

The 11 year term is the maximum sentence for manslaughter and he will serve 85% of that term.

Earlier Chapters:



  • Sad situation all around…

  • No cannabis tag kym?

  • Cali’s laws are messed up. How is there an 11 year max sentence on manslaughter, 9.35 with time off. Seems like a slap on the wrist for killing a man and attempting to kill two others, wrecklessly firing into the night in a town full of people over weed. Sickening.

    • They went there to rob him over heroin and took the pot as collateral using intimidation he waited for his chance to get to his gun is why they were shot while leaving if they would of charged him with murder he would of gotten off

      • Where he went wrong was going outside his residence and fired the shots, nothing good has come from any of this two mothers have lost their boys, one forever the other may not make it home, I hope we can all learn from their mistakes and move on, live by the sword die by the sword.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *