Evidence Is Presented and Jury Selection Begins in Trial of Gary Bullock

John Chiv covers the local legal system for his blog. He shares his observations on some of the more high profile trials with us in our Humboldt Justice guest column.

bullock feature

Gary Bullock in court soon after he was arrested for the murder of Father Freed. [Photo by Mark McKenna]

On December 31st, 2013, Father Freed prepared for a New Year’s mass. But when the next day’s celebration was to occur, he was instead found murdered. The story of a Catholic priest killed in his home next to his church became national news.

A Southern Humboldt man from a prominent family, Gary Bullock, was soon arrested and charged with first degree murder.

John Chiv covers today’s court proceedings for us below, on his blog here and also here. The morning was mostly concerned with jury selection and the afternoon was taken up with reviewing evidence and deciding what the jury will hear. Chiv writes,


John Chiv

Jury selection started today in the jury trial for Gary Lee Bullock.

Judge John Feeney met privately with attorneys, Deputy District Attorney Andrew Issac and Kaleb Cockrum as well as DA Investigator John Burke.

Bullock dressed in a white shirt and gray slacks silently next to Mr. Cockrum, occassionally glancing at the audience.

Two family members, including Bullock’s brother-in-law and two people who knew Fr. Eric Freed came though one had to leave before court opened. The other is a parishioner who has attended most of the court hearings in the last two years.

A jury panel,originaly scheduled for an attempted murder case filled out the first hardship questionnaire. Those that were not excused will fill out the long questionnaire this afternoon and be asked to call after 5 p.m. tomorrow. Another jury panel will fill out the hardship questionnaire tomorrow morning.

A 402 or evidentiary hearing is being held this afternoon with DA Investigator Burke, DA Computer Specialist Martin Perrone and former Eureka Police Detective Todd Wilcox, who now works for the Humboldt County Sheriff’s office. Tomorrow Sgt. Jesse Taylor from Garberville and Department of Justice’s Kay Belchner are supposed to testify also. An evidentiary hearing took place this afternoon in the Gary Lee Bullock case.

Video surveilance from St. Bernards Church, google maps, church blue prints, audio of four phone calls and visitations made by Bullock to his grandmother and wife and with his mother and step father were admitted into evidence. A snippet of the phone call with Bullock pleading to his grandmother to bail him out on Jan 7, 2014 was played. In the snippet, Bullock’s grandmother said, “I will not lose my house over your drug use.”

She says no to him several times in the selection. We heard, “If I let you out, you will go back to drugs.” Bullock says he won’t. She says she has heard that before. Then she says, “You killed somebody.” He responds, “No, I didn’t. I ‘ll explain it to you.”

Video recording made from surveillance cameras all over St. Bernard’s property, one inside the church, the rest exterior covering the grounds, the rectory, the church, the bathrooms and other buildings which was shown at the preliminary hearing was played, identified and admitted into evidence. The video covers the times between midnight and 7 a.m. on January 1, 2014 and was prepared by DA Investigator Martin Perrone who specializes in computer crimes for the D.A’s office. Although, exhibit number 7, the interview of Bullock at the Eureka Police Department with EPD Detective Ron Harpham and DA Investigators Wayne Cox and John Burke was identified, how much of that the jury will hear will be decided on March 7. Defense is objecting to the entire interview, but is fine with select portions. Both attorneys will present arguments on March 7, 2016 as well as other motions will be heard that day.

Trial is expected to conclude by or before April 18, 2016.The jury trial will be in session five days a week; Monday to Thursday full days from 8:30 to 4 and Friday mornings from 8:30 until noon. There are a few days in March and early April that the trial will not be in session. Bullock is charged with

Count 1 murder with three special allegations: infliction of torture, murder committed while engaging in first degree residential burglary and murder committed during carjacking. Count 2 and 3 are both first degree residential burglary. Count 4 Vehicle theft. Count 5 arson of inhabitated structure. Count 6 is carjacking and Count 7 is Torture.



  • Yes finely!I’ve been waiting for his trial,and hope he gets what’s coming to him,and the help he needs!Rest in peace father Freed!!

  • Thank you John for your blog great coverage on this tragedy. I hope and pray this monster is prosecuted to the full extent of the law. RIP Father Freed.

  • Thank you Xena. I appreciate Kym giving me the opportunity to reach a wider audience.

  • I’ve been eagerly waiting for the beginning of this trial. Father Freed was one of my high school teachers; a kind, non-judgmental, interesting man. I look forward to reading updates on the trial and seeing justice be served.

  • I appreciate your work, and I hope you can keep us posted on RB as the trial goes along. Thanks. af

  • Drugboldt County

    “A Southern Humboldt man from a prominent family”


  • Our family knew FR Freed well not only as a Priest, a teacher but as a dear friend, in fact he was the Trustee of our family trust.

    Our son was his student and teaching assistant in high school, and Fr Freed was our son’s confidant while he was away in LA while attending college. Fr Freed remembered all the important stuff in our son’s life and even called him the night before our son’s Bar exam to wish him well, inspire him and let him know he was praying for his success. Fr. Freed always told our son I’m here for you and I’m the guy that will be there to marry you and baptize your children some day but not going to happen due to Bullock.

    Fr. Freed was a great pries and great and kind man and he became a great friend of our family. For someone to do this to this man is more than a crime.

    Fr Freed is still telling us from Heaven to forgive this guy and he probably was asking God to do so in his last breaths, but I hope this guy rots in prison and then burns for eternity in Hell.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *